What is a Shaker Meyer Lemon Pie? It is a traditional Shaker recipe using meyer lemons which are sliced thinly, peel and all, marinated in sugar overnight, then mixed with eggs and put in a double crust. The lemons are unsprayed, so you don’t get any pesticides with your pie.
Hand Pie 3.60
• Spinach and Onion
• Mixed Mushrooms and Goat Gouda
• Jamaican Meat Patty
• Mince & Onion
Pot Pie 6.50
• Ham ‘n’ Eggs
• Spinach ‘n’ Eggs
Side of Mixed Organic Greens 1.90 / A Plate of Mixed Greens 3.95
Coconut Spinach Soup (vegetarian) 3.95
3.75/slice 18/whole 4/Mini
A scoop of Straus Vanilla Ice Cream 2.00
Shoofly Pie • Coconut Cream • Rhubarb Pie • Banana Cream Pie • Chocolate Pudding Pie Lemon Meringue • Dutch Apple Pie • Peanut Butter • Lemon Pie
Almond Fromage Blanc Cake • German Chocolate Coconut Pie
We recommend ordering full-size pies in advance.
Unless indicated in the menu, gluten-free,* sugar-free, or vegan pies require ordering in advance.
* We are not a gluten-free facility. Pie orders cheerfully accepted for birthdays, weddings and other special events.